These homemade strawberry pop-tarts are made with an easy, flaky, buttery pastry crust, filled with a candy-like fresh (homemade) strawberry jam, and iced with a simple glaze.
I never reached for the Strawberry Pop-Tarts as a kid. Pass me the chocolate, the cookies ‘n cream, the brown sugar & cinnamon (especially the brown sugar & cinnamon — make it two packs), but not the strawberry. When it came to strawberry (or blueberry), just no-thank-you, keep your fruit away from my snacks, please.
Even now as a (supposed) adult, I’ll almost always pick something chocolate over something fruit-filled.
But…. But, last weekend Zach and I spent over an hour poring over the strawberry plants of a local field until our fingers were stained red (and our shoulders sun-stained as well… oops) and our baskets were heavy. Really heavy… I’m talking 14 pounds of strawberries between the two of us.
And here’s the good/bad thing about these local-grown, hand-picked strawberries. They’re not sprayed with preservatives (awesome), so they go bad fast (not so awesome). Despite the pounds of strawberries we were able to devour within twenty minutes of bringing them through the door, I still had a hefty basket of berries on hand that I had to make quick work of (I had this same problem when we went strawberry picking last year).
And even though I’d never liked strawberry pop-tarts as a kid, I couldn’t help but think I bet if I made some from scratch with these berries, I’d love it.
I was so right.
Not only did Zach and I both enjoy these pop tarts, my whole family loved them as well. I even got a disgruntled text message from my sister Nikki, who arrived home to find only one pop tart left, telling me that pop tarts were supposed to come in packs of two and she felt ripped off. I get it. These pop tarts with their sweet homemade jam filling are amazing, and it’s almost a shame to eat just one.
The riper the strawberries are that you use for this recipe, the better. Ours tasted like sweet, juicy candy straight off the vine, so they made for a vibrantly red, boisterously flavorful filling. If it’s not strawberry season near you and the only picking you can do is surveying the berries through the film of a plastic carton, that’s fine and you should still make these. I just highly recommend that you select the juiciest, ripest ones you can find.
I used the same flaky, tender crust here that I used for my chocolate turnovers. It bakes up nice and golden in the oven under the sheen of an egg wash (and is the absolute easiest pie crust I’ve ever used). It’s the perfect encasement for the sweet strawberry jam, flaky and soft inside with a browned exterior.
Add a little bit of sweet glaze and a lot of sprinkles, and you’ve got yourself the best pop tarts you’ll ever taste.
Sweet and nostalgic.
You still won’t find me reaching for the store-bought strawberry pop tarts anytime soon, but I think I’ll be making this recipe again.
Enjoy, and if you have any requests for future pop tart recipes on Sugar Spun Run I’d love to hear them! 🙂
More Recipes to Try:
Homemade Strawberry Pop Tarts
Ingredients
Strawberry Filling*
- 2 cups quartered stems-removed strawberries
- 1/2 cup sugar
- 2 tsp cornstarch
- 2 tsp lemon juice
- 1/4 tsp vanilla extract optional
Pastry Crust
- 2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 Tbsp sugar
- 1/2 tsp salt
- 13 Tbsp unsalted sweet cream butter cold and cut into pieces (about 1 Tbsp-sized pieces)
- 1/2 cup sour cream
Egg Wash
- 1 egg lightly beaten
- 2 tsp water
Glaze
- 1 cup powdered sugar
- 3-4 Tbsp heavy cream
- 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
- Sprinkles if desired
Instructions
Filling
- In a medium-sized saucepan, combine strawberries, sugar, cornstarch, and lemon juice over medium-low heat.
- Stir frequently until strawberries release their juices.
- Use a potato masher to crush the strawberries until mostly liquid (it's fine if small pieces are remaining).
- Increase heat to medium-high and bring to a boil, stirring constantly.
- Boil (still stirring constantly) for 3 minutes and remove from heat.
- Stir in vanilla extract. Continue to occasionally stir the mixture so that it doesn't burn to the bottom of the pan.
- Pour into a canning jar and place in the refrigerator until you are ready to use.
Pastry Crust
- In a food processor, pulse together flour, sugar, and salt.
- Sprinkle in chopped, cold butter and pulse until coarse crumbs begin to form.
- Add the sour cream and pulse until the dough begins to clump together.
- Deposit the dough out onto clean, well-floured surface and lightly dust with more flour.
- Knead dough, adding flour as needed, until it is cohesive and no longer sticky
- Using your palm, flatten the dough on the clean surface.
- Fold the dough into itself twice and repeat the flattening process (this helps encourage flaky layers in the crust).
- Repeat the folding and flattening process once more.
- Divide the pastry dough into two pieces and form each into a smooth ball. Slightly flatten into a disk, wrap tightly with clear wrap and place in fridge to chill for at least 30 minutes.
- After the dough has chilled, remove from refrigerator.
- Remove clear wrap from dough (working with one disk at a time) and turn dough out onto a clean, lightly floured surface.
- Use a rolling pin to roll each disk into a roughly 9x12 rectangle (I always make it larger and then trim the edges, I use a pizza cutter for even cuts).
- Cut into 3x4 pieces (I'm a stickler so I use a ruler to make sure they're even, but this isn't necessary and even still my pop tarts end up with slightly varied sizes).
- Place two 3x4 piece of crust on a parchment paper lined cookie sheet.
- Prepare your egg wash by stirring together your egg and 2 tsp of water with a fork until well-combined.
- Brush the surfaces of both pastry pieces with egg wash using a pastry brush (do not discard the egg wash, you will use it again before putting the pop tarts in the oven).
- Place 1 heaping Tbsp of filling in the center of one piece of crust, and then place the second piece of pastry on top (the egg-washed side should be facing the filling).
- Crimp the edges with a fork to seal, and then use a sharp knife to pierce small holes throughout the pastry.
- Repeat until all of your dough has been used.
- Chill pop tarts on cookie sheet in refrigerator for 20 minutes.
- Once pop tarts have finished chilling, brush with remaining egg wash and transfer to oven.
- Bake on 400 for 25 minutes or until edges are beginning to turn golden-brown.
- Allow to cool completely before frosting.
Glaze
- Prepare glaze by whisking together powdered sugar, heavy cream, and vanilla extract.
- Spread over each pop tart and decorate with sprinkles, if desired.
- Allow the pop tarts to sit at least 10-15 minutes for the frosting to set.
- Enjoy!
Notes
Unlike storebought pop-tarts, once these have been frosted they won't hold up to a toaster (the icing will melt right off). I like to pop mine in the microwave for a few seconds, just be warned that the icing becomes pretty melty when heated.
Nutrition
Kimmie Leonard says
These are so yummy! Definitely tastier than a boxed Poptart. I’m excited to make them again, have you ever made them in different flavors?
Sugar Spun Run says
I am so glad that you enjoyed them, Kimmie! I have not personally made them in other flavors, however, others have with success. Strawberry was a favorite of mine as a kid so I have stuck with that. Brown sugar would be good… If you try another flavor, I’d love to know how they turn out! 🙂
Pamela says
Best pop tart ever. A+
Sugar Spun Run says
I am so glad that you enjoyed it, Pamela! Thank you! 🙂
Chris Smith says
These look amazing! I want to try them with my grandkids! Once the pop tarts are made, can you freeze them so the kids can pull one out and defrost?
Sam says
Hi, Chris! I have not tried this so I can’t be 100% certain. I believe the pop-tart and filling would freeze just fine, but I would be worried about the frosting not maintaining its texture and taste after being frozen. 🙂
Renee Roush says
I just made this crust a second time and would like to keep it for a couple of weeks as I’m preparing all the desserts for my brother in law’s engagement party. Do you think it would freeze well?
Sam says
Hi Renee! I think it will freeze just fine just make sure it’s wrapped well.
Renee says
These are terrific! I’ve actually tried many pop tart recipes and this crust is LE-GIT! I will make this crust exclusively from here on out, no matter the filling I use. On other sites, I’ve heard these referred to as “hand pies” and I think this name applies well here. You’re correct that they won’t reheat in a toaster, and the crust is too fluffy and flaky to really be “pop-tart-like”… Mostly because actual boxed pop tarts are thin (and GROSS, in my opinion). If you want the actual pop tart sized crust, I recommend using a traditional pie crust and not the sour cream crust used here. BUT. Truth be told, these are like seventy five times tastier than boxed pop tarts, no matter the thickness of the crust or the method needed to reheat, and you should absolutely make these IMMEDIATELY!!!!!!!
Sam says
Yay! So glad you enjoyed them so much, Renee!! Thank you for commenting!! 🙂
KL says
My kids enjoyed helping me make these.
Sam says
So glad to hear it! 🙂
Annie Abbey says
These look absolutely amazing! I love strawberry pop tarts but there is so much junk in them! Making your own means no preservatives 🙂
xx Annie
Sam says
Thank you so much Annie! YES that might just be the best thing about these! 🙂
Amanda says
I’m pretty much exclusively a chocolate dessert and treat person, but the one exception was strawberry Pop Tarts. They were always in the house. These look a billion times better. So tender and flakey!
Hira says
These are adorable, Sam! My favorite flavor pop-tarts were the milkshake variety… sadly they got discontinued a couple of years ago. Also, your pictures are GORGEOUS (as usual). 🙂
Sam says
OH man, milkshake pop tarts!? They sound amazing, I guess I never saw them when they were around! Thank you so much, Hira! 🙂 🙂
Sues says
These are so pretty!! And yes, perfectly nostalgic 🙂
Sam says
Thank you, Sues! 🙂
Medha @ Whisk & Shout says
These homemade pop tarts look amazing! Ted’s Bulletin in DC is famous for making their own pop tarts, but I would rather avoid the trek and make mine at home 🙂
Sam says
Ooh, if I’m ever in the DC area again I will have to look them up! Until then I’ll definitely be making them at home, though! 🙂